Valve Type: Fire-Safe Valve

As the first manufacturer of fusible link valves in China, certfied ATEX, CE, PED, UL/FM, SIL3, ISO9001, and ISO14001. Our fusible link valves are trusted by customers worldwide for their high quality, competitive pricing, and fast delivery. Whether you are a buyer, distributor, or engineering company in the oil, chemical, energy or IT infrastructure industries, we can provide you with the best solutions. 

Don't Let Your Competitors Get Ahead of You.

First manufacturer of fusible link valves in China, which bring you more advantage in your business.

Comprehensive Guide to Fire-Safe Valve Design and Testing

In engineering processes, industrial valves installed in fire-prone areas must be fire-safe. If the process requires the valve to have “fire resistance, anti-static, and anti-ejection” technical requirements, a fire-safe design is necessary. Reliable fire safety must be provided in sensitive applications such as refining, oil and gas, and petrochemicals. These valves should ensure safe and reliable shutdown during fire incidents, making fire-safe design crucial for them. This article will comprehensively explore the design considerations for fire-safe valves, the principles of fire testing, and fire testing requirements.

What is a Fire-Safe Valve?

A fire-safe valve is an industrial valve specifically designed to maintain its operational functionality in the event of a fire. These valves are typically used in high-risk environments like refining, oil and gas, and chemicals, as well as in renewable energy generator systems, particularly diesel storage tank generator systems. Fire-safe valves are often installed at the inlet and outlet of storage tanks to prevent the spread of fire and ensure safety. They undergo rigorous fire testing, such as API 607, API 6FA, and ISO 10497, to ensure they can effectively shut off and prevent the leakage of flammable and explosive media at high temperatures. Common types of fire-safe valves include ball valves, butterfly valves, and check valves, with sealing materials usually made of multilayer sealing structures and high-temperature-resistant materials like graphite, TELON, and PEEK seals.

Process Requirements for Fire Safety

Process requirements for valve fire safety are generally divided into two scenarios:

Emergency Shut-off Valve

The emgergency shutoff valve normally open, and it specifically engineered to stop the flow of liquid in situations where there is a fire or the temperatures get too high. This type of emergency shut-off valve is typically placed in the fuel line that runs from a storage tank to equipment that burns fuel, include back-up generators which are used when the main power goes out, boilers which provide heating, and various other appliances that burn flammable liquids to operate. By cutting off the liquid flow during emergencies, this valve helps to prevent potentially dangerous situations from worsening.

Valves for Continuous Operation

To meet the needs of the process for continuous operation during a fire incident, it is important to ensure that all safety measures and protocols are in place. This will help in maintaining the ongoing functions without any interruptions even when a fire breaks out.

What is Fire Safety Measures for Valves

Chemical plants typically operate in enclosed environments, and in chemical control systems with high fire risks, valves act as the terminal control devices of the regulation system. They are crucial components of the chemical pipeline system, receiving manual or automatic signals to control chemical processes, regulating pressure, preventing backflow, and maintaining stable pressure and leakage. When overpressure occurs, these valves can quickly release excess flammable and explosive media, ensuring the safe operation of pressure vessels and pipeline systems, and preventing fire accidents. When a fire occurs, valves with specific fire-resistant performance can continue to operate normally in high-temperature flames, preventing the leakage of flammable and explosive media and ensuring the safety of production equipment and personnel. Therefore, implementing corresponding fire safety measures for valves is of great significance. Different valves have different specifications and fire testing methods, but specific fire safety measures can be formulated by analyzing the valve structure and causes of fire safety failures.

How to Fire Safety Measures Based on Valve Body Performance

1. Minimizing Internal Leakage During a Fire

Under normal operating pressure, if the sealing surface between the valve core and the valve body leaks beyond allowable limits, it can lead to continuous loss of media. Commonly, the sealing surfaces of control valves are metal-to-metal, and continuous leakage can damage the hard sealing materials. Achieving zero leakage under pressurized conditions is very challenging. Therefore, during a fire, regardless of the valve’s sealing structure, spring force, or external pressure changes, the primary consideration should be ensuring metal-to-metal contact between the valve core and valve body to minimize internal leakage. This prevents flammable media from entering the fire. Methods to reduce internal leakage during a fire include regular valve maintenance, ensuring the quality of the sealing surface, improving sealing material quality to reduce damage, and proper valve selection to avoid erosion and cavitation.

2. Minimizing External Leakage During a Fire

External leakage of valves typically falls into three scenarios:

a) Insufficient or Uneven Bolt Tightening on Joint Surfaces: This causes poor sealing. The solution is to adjust the bolt tightness using a diagonal tightening method while measuring the gaps until the desired torque is reached, ensuring consistent gaps.

b) Non-Standard Serrated Gaskets on Joint Surfaces: Radial scratches, poor parallelism, overly sharp or steep serrations can lead to sealing failure and leakage. Ensuring the quality of spare parts by using standard serrated gaskets can prevent this issue.

c) Poor Flatness or Hard Debris on Joint Surfaces: This can cause sealing failure. The valve should be disassembled, and the joint surfaces should be re-ground to meet quality standards. Clean the surfaces during assembly to prevent debris from entering.

To minimize external leakage during a fire, fire-resistant stem sealing materials should be used, avoid large gasket-style body connections, and improve the fire resistance of various materials.

3. Ensuring Continuous Stable Operation During a Fire

To prevent fire hazards from escalating into large-scale fires or chain explosions and to create favorable conditions for other firefighting measures, it is crucial to ensure that valves can operate normally and continuously after burning. Achieving this requires that not only the valve body components meet fire safety requirements, but also the actuators and their piping and wiring adopt fire-safe designs.

Fire Safety for Actuators

Actuators use liquid, gas, electricity, or other energy sources converted by motors, cylinders, or other devices to drive operations. Common types include pneumatic and electric actuators. Pneumatic actuators receive air pressure signals from controllers or positioners, converting them into linear displacement to drive the valve, mainly diaphragm or piston types. Electric actuators use electrical power as the driving energy, typically using three-phase power for large valves and single-phase power for smaller valves.

In industrial applications, valves typically use spring-type pneumatic diaphragm actuators. During a fire, the low melting point diaphragm quickly fails, causing the spring to move the valve to a safe position. Piston-type reciprocating spring actuators have fusible plugs that melt at specific temperatures, releasing cylinder pressure and allowing the spring or compressed air to move the valve to a safe position. Some valves use electric actuators with spring return functions, which, upon reaching the melting point of fusible components during a fire, activate the actuator’s trigger to drive the valve to a safe position.

To ensure actuators function normally after catching fire, three protective methods can be used: fireproof coatings, sprinklers, or insulation materials.

Fireproof Coatings on Actuators: Applying fireproof coatings can ensure actuators operate normally during a fire. Tests have shown that actuators can function for 42 minutes in flames reaching 760–927°C with such coatings, with springs and seals remaining unaffected. Care must be taken not to cover sealing parts during application, and actuators with aluminum shells are not recommended due to their low melting points.

Sprinkler Systems on Actuators: Automatic sprinklers can extinguish fires and cool down the actuators, but they pose significant risks as water supply systems are often damaged during fires. They also require substantial installation space and maintenance costs, increasing investment.

Fireproof Hoods Made of Insulating Materials: Fireproof hoods control temperature changes within, ensuring actuators’ temperature rise does not exceed 30–40°C within 30 minutes (normal ambient temperature around 40°C, actuator failure temperature 70–80°C). These hoods are flexible, easy to maintain, and ideal for chemical plant valves. They can be customized based on valve shapes and made from high thermal insulation materials like mineral wool, wrapped in a special metal frame for effective isolation. However, they occupy significant space, require custom designs, and need professional removal and inspection during maintenance outages.

What is Valve Fire Testing?

The American Petroleum Institute (API) has established fire tests for valves used in the oil and gas industry, such as ISO 10497, API 607, API 6FA, BS 5146, and BS 6755. These tests consider the causes and spread of fires, the type of fluids used, the peak temperatures during a fire, the valve’s sealing integrity, and the valve’s capabilities after the fire.

Common Fire-Safe Design Standards

API 607 Fire Test for Quarter-Turn Valves and Non-Metallic Seated Valves

Scope: This standard applies to quarter-turn valves and non-metallic seated valves, such as ball valves, butterfly valves, and plug valves. The following valve devices are not covered by this standard: fire test requirements for drive devices (e.g., electric, pneumatic, hydraulic) other than manual gearboxes or similar mechanisms, which are typically part of the valve assembly. API 607 is for soft-seated (non-metallic) valves and cannot be used for metal-seated valves.

Detailed Process for API 607 Fire Certification:

  1. Design Review: Submit the design drawings to a third-party review.
  2. Test Facility Engagement: Contact the test facility, fill out the test request form, and provide the complete product design and manufacturing documentation along with certifications.
  3. Test Scheduling: Schedule the test date with the facility.
  4. Witnessing: Have representatives from the three parties (manufacturer, third party, and test facility) present to witness the fire test.
  5. Fire Test Execution: The test facility conducts the fire test and issues a report.
  6. Certification: Based on the test report, the third party issues the fire test certificate.
  7. Critical Considerations: Ensure reasonable selection of prototype size and pressure. Once the test passes, certification is granted.

Scope: This standard applies to API 6A and API 6D valves, such as ball valves, gate valves, and plug valves. The API 6FA fire test specification is a universal standard that can be used for both soft-seated and metal-seated valves; check valves are not covered by this standard.

Scope: This standard specifically applies to check valves.

Scope: ISO 10497 is a fire test standard for manually operated valves. It excludes the fire test requirements for drive devices (e.g., electric, pneumatic, hydraulic) other than manual gearboxes or similar mechanisms that are part of the valve assembly. ISO 10497 certification provides a global standard for valve fire testing, ensuring valves can maintain a tight shutoff when exposed to fire.

Additional Information

Often, in various materials, valves are said to have fire-resistant functions. This is not entirely accurate. For example, API 607’s standard title is “Fire Test for Soft Seated Quarter-Turn Valves”; API 6FA is titled “Specification for Fire Test for Valves.” Therefore, the correct term should be that the valve has fire-resistant properties. This document does not strictly differentiate between these terms.

Standards and Definitions:

  • API 6FA, API 6FD, API 607, and ISO 10497: For the purpose of this specification, the terms “fire test” and “fire testing” are identical. To date, no single test or definition can definitively determine whether a valve is fire-resistant. However, many industrial societies, oil companies, insurance companies, valve manufacturers, and related institutions in the UK and US have established various fire test methods for valves.

Definition:

  • Fire Resistance of Valves: This is the ability of a valve to maintain normal operation in high-temperature flames. It is a crucial indicator of valve safety performance. The fire test is the only method to determine its fire resistance. It should be noted that having fire-resistant properties does not mean the valve will not leak at all in high-temperature flames; instead, it means the valve can tolerate a certain amount of leakage within a specified time.

Fire Test Diameter and Pressure Rating Evaluation:

  1. Diameter Coverage: Typically, a valve with a smaller diameter can cover a larger diameter range. For example, an NPS 6 valve can cover diameters from NPS 6 to NPS 12, and a DN 100 valve can cover diameters from DN 100 to DN 200.
  2. Pressure Rating Coverage: Pressure ratings also have specified coverage ranges. For instance, a PN 25 valve can cover pressure ratings from PN 25 to PN 40.
  3. Multiple Valve Models: If multiple valve models need testing, an engineer can evaluate how many test reports are required.

API 607 Fire Testing for Valve

API 607 is a critical standard established by the American Petroleum Institute (API) for fire testing quarter-turn valves with non-metallic seating. This standard ensures that such valves can maintain their integrity and functionality during and after a fire, preventing leakage of flammable or hazardous materials.

Scope and Applicability

API 607 specifically applies to quarter-turn valves and other types of valves that utilize non-metallic seating, including:

  • Ball valves
  • Butterfly valves
  • Plug valves

The standard does not cover actuators or other valve accessories unless they are integral to the valve’s operation.

Acceptance Criteria

To pass the API 607 fire test, valves must meet the following acceptance criteria:

  • Internal Leakage: The leakage through the valve’s seat must be within the limits specified by the standard.
  • External Leakage: Leakage from the valve body, bonnet, or other components must not exceed the specified limits.
  • Operational Integrity: The valve must be operable after the fire test, with no significant increase in operating torque or damage that would impair its function.
  • Post-Test Inspection: The valve must be inspected for any damage or deformation that could affect its performance.

Importance of API 607 Certification

Valves that pass the API 607 fire test demonstrate:

  • Enhanced Safety: Ensuring minimal leakage during and after a fire, thereby reducing the risk of fire spread and potential explosions.
  • Reliability: Maintaining operational integrity under extreme conditions, crucial for emergency shutdown systems in hazardous environments.
  • Regulatory Compliance: Meeting industry standards and regulatory requirements for fire-safe valves, often a prerequisite for installations in refineries, petrochemical plants, and other high-risk areas.

API 607 Fire Test Procedure

The fire test for valves under API 607 includes the following key requirements and procedures:

  1. Pre-Test Inspection:

    • Valves must be visually inspected for defects.
    • The valve’s design, materials, and manufacturing process must be documented.
  2. Test Setup:

    • Valves are installed in a test rig that simulates actual operating conditions.
    • The valve is subjected to a pressure test with water or a specified test fluid to ensure there are no initial leaks.
  3. Fire Exposure:

    • The valve is exposed to direct flames at temperatures between 750°C and 1000°C (1382°F and 1832°F) for a minimum duration of 30 minutes.
    • The test aims to simulate a realistic fire scenario, ensuring that the valve’s fire-safe design can withstand extreme conditions.
  4. Leakage Measurement:

    • During the fire exposure, the valve’s external and internal leakage is measured.
    • The permissible leakage rates are strictly defined to ensure safety. Typically, leakage must be within acceptable limits as defined by the standard.
  5. Post-Fire Testing:

    • After the fire exposure, the valve is allowed to cool naturally.
    • A pressure test is conducted to ensure that the valve can still hold the specified pressure without significant leakage.
  6. Operational Testing:

    • The valve must be operated (opened and closed) to verify that it still functions correctly after fire exposure.
    • Any binding, excessive torque, or failure to operate is recorded.
  7. Documentation and Reporting:

    • Detailed records of the test conditions, procedures, and results must be maintained.
    • A test report is generated, documenting the valve’s performance against the API 607 criteria.

Principles of Valve Fire Testing

According to widely accepted firefighting strategies, if a fire cannot be extinguished within 30 minutes, evacuation and containment strategies are implemented. Fire tests last for 30 minutes to ensure that fire-safe valves can operate after exposure to high temperatures. During the test, the valve is filled with water and operated at temperatures between 750-1000°C (1382-1832°F) for 30 minutes, while monitoring the external and internal leakage of the sealing areas and seats. If the leakage exceeds acceptable limits, the valve may not be suitable for fire-safe applications.

Fire Safe Design vs. Fire Testing

When selecting fire-safe valves, the terms “fire safe design” and “fire testing” sound similar but have different meanings.

Fire Safe Design

Fire protection features are considered in the design but are not specifically tested for fire performance.

Fire Testing

Valves are tested by manufacturers or testing facilities but lack approval from third-party authoritative organizations.

Fire Certification

Comprehensive testing, approval, and certification by an authorized third-party organization.

Design Requirements for Fire-Safe Valves

Fire-safe valves are installed in pipelines or equipment in flammable and explosive environments. When a fire occurs, they can continue to operate normally or isolate materials in an emergency. Both pneumatic and electric valves use fire safety measures such as fireproof hoods. Additionally, fire-resistant cables and fireproof wrapping for gas supply lines and cable trays are needed to achieve overall fire safety.

Sealing Positions for Valves

Key design details for valve sealing include:

  1. The flange connection sealing surface between the valve boonet and valve body typically uses a gasket.
  2. The sealing between the valve stem and valve body usually employs packing seals.
  3. The sealing between the valve core and valve body relies on machining precision and sealing material properties, such as hard alloys.
  4. For valves with upper sealing structures, the sealing after the valve is opened typically uses packing seals.
  5. Bellows sealing structures prevent media from flowing into the upper valve cover, enhancing the sealing between the valve stem and valve body.
  6. The flange connection sealing surface between the front and back of the valve body and the
  7. pipeline generally uses a gasket.

Understanding valve sealing performance helps identify leakage points and propose different anti-leakage measures, which significantly guide the overall fire-safe design of valves.

Fire-Safe Ball Valve Design

a. Fire-Safe Float Type Ball Valve

In the closed position, when the seal ring is burned away, the ball remains in position. For floating ball valves with fireproof requirements, three key aspects need attention:

  1. The gasket material between the valve body and cover should be stainless steel + graphite, like 304 + graphite or 316 + graphite, which do not burn at high temperatures and maintain sealing performance, preventing leaks in the valve’s middle section.
  2. Packing material should be graphite, which is high-temperature resistant and maintains good sealing performance even in a fire, ensuring the valve stem’s sealing at high temperatures.
  3. The fireproof shoulder should be designed at the valve body and cover’s seal ring installation area. When the seal ring burns away, the ball can rely on the fireproof shoulder to ensure a certain level of sealing performance.

Through these three points, floating ball valves can effectively achieve their fireproof performance in a fire.

Key components include the valve body, gasket, valve bonnet, sealing ring, ball, packing, and packing gland. When the sealing ring is burned away, the ball can rely on the fireproof boss for a certain sealing performance. Key considerations:

  1. Valve Body    2. Gasket   3. Valve Cover   4. Seal Ring    5. Ball    6. Packing    7. Packing Gland

b. Fire-Safe Trunnion Type Ball Valve

In the closed position, when the seal ring is burned away, the ball remains in position. For trunnion ball valves with fireproof requirements, three key aspects need attention:

  1. The gasket material between the valve body and cover, valve body and rear cover, and valve body and packing box should be stainless steel + graphite, like 304 + graphite or 316 + graphite, for the same reasons as floating ball valves.
  2. Packing material should be graphite for the same reasons as floating ball valves.
  3. The support ring’s outer diameter should be designed with wrapped asbestos rope, and a fireproof shoulder should be designed on the inner circle near the ball surface. When the O-ring and seal ring are burned away, the asbestos rope and fireproof shoulder provide a certain level of sealing performance.

Through these three points, trunnion ball valves can effectively achieve their fireproof performance in a fire.

Key components include the valve cover, gasket, valve body, back cover, asbestos rope, ball, sealing ring, support ring, packing, packing gland, and trunnion. Key considerations:

  1. Valve Cover    2. Gasket   3. Valve Body   4. Rear Cover   5. Gasket   6. Asbestos Rope   7. Ball   8. Seal Ring   9. Support Ring   10. Gasket    11. Packing    12. Packing Box    13. Packing Gland

Fire Testing of Actuated Valves

Actuated valves consist of two main components: the actuator and the valve body. The fire protection design requirements for these components are specified in SH/T 3005—2016. According to this standard, if the process requires the actuated valve to have fire protection, a fire-safe control valve meeting API 607 or API 6FA standards should be selected. Additionally, the fire protection requirements for shutoff valves should comply with the relevant provisions and process requirements of GB 50160—2008. For example, “The extraction pipeline of LPG equipment should be equipped with a shutoff valve near the base of the equipment. If the volume of the LPG equipment exceeds 50 m³ and the fire distance between the equipment and its extraction pump is less than 15 meters, the shutoff valve should be a remotely controlled valve with manual functionality. The local operation button of the remote control valve should not be less than 15 meters from the extraction pump.” There are no specific fire test requirements for electric, pneumatic, or hydraulic actuators in the related standard testing procedures.

Exclusions and Additional Standards:

  • API 607:2010 clearly states that actuators are excluded from the standard’s scope.
  • UL 1709:2007: Onshore valve actuators should meet this standard, which involves withstanding hydrocarbon pool fires at 1093°C for 30 minutes.
  • ISO 22899:2007: Offshore valve actuators should meet this standard, which involves withstanding hydrocarbon jet fires at 1300°C with an overpressure of 0.29 MPa.

In most industrial applications, valves are not exposed to fires or other extreme temperatures. Under normal operations, the interface between the valve body and closure components should be capable of sealing shut. Users demand that valves exhibit both excellent sealing performance and fire resistance during normal operations. Many manufacturers address this complex requirement by developing various “soft” and “hard” sealing assemblies. Both types of assemblies should maintain metal-to-metal contact sealing after being exposed to fire. Hard seals are typically made of metal or hard alloys, which are inherently fire-resistant. Soft seals are made from PTFE, PEEK, or other elastic materials with melting points below 370°C. While soft seals may degrade in a fire, the system’s pressure, valve plate rotation force, spring force, or gravity should maintain metal-to-metal contact. However, the post-fire safety of many soft-seated valves is not ideal, necessitating stricter standards for testing, analyzing, and comparing the fire performance of valves.

SH/T 3005—2016 specifies that “switching valves should use metal-seated valve seats and internal components, fire-resistant gaskets, and enhanced flexible graphite packing. Metal sealing requirements can also be achieved through specially designed soft-seated valve seats, ensuring that when the soft seat melts during a fire, the valve ultimately achieves metal-to-metal sealing.”

Fire resistance in valves is defined as the ability to maintain normal operation in high-temperature flames. Fire testing is the only method to determine a valve’s fire resistance. Different manufacturers’ valves may only meet one or two fire standards. Fire performance testing not only includes API and ISO regulations but also other national and organizational standards, such as European BS standards, which should be distinguished in practical engineering applications.

In Case of Severe Fire: Manufacturers provide two options:

  • Fire-Safe Valves

Made of strong materials and seals, these valves are designed to withstand high temperatures without damage.

  • Fail-Safe Mode

Typically achieved through springs or compressed air in pneumatic actuators. Electric actuators may include backup batteries or mechanical spring mechanisms.

Fire Shield Design Requirements

1. Operational Temperature Calculation

Calculate the actuator’s operating temperature based on the maximum environmental temperature and the highest temperature of the medium flowing through the valve.

2. Failure Temperature Compliance

Ensure that electric actuators have a failure temperature of 70°C and pneumatic actuators have a failure temperature of 80°C.

3. Design Integration

Combine the detailed dimensions and layout conditions of the valve and actuator to finalize the fire shield design.

4. Fire Shield Construction

The fire shield consists of multiple layers: fiberglass, stainless steel mesh, high-density ceramic wool, and fiberglass.

  • The metal frame is made from Fe360 with anti-corrosion coating, and special fire-expanding gaskets are installed at all pipe connections entering and exiting the shield.
  • Design parameters include the fire shield’s outer dimensions, window sizes and positions, and dimensions and locations of cable and air source openings.

 

Advantages of Using Fire Shields

  • Strapping used for securing can be easily and safely installed and maintained without special tools or personnel.
  • The fire shield can be easily removed and reinstalled for maintenance without moving equipment or disconnecting instruments.
  • Fire shields allow for manual operation of valves and instruments without needing to be moved.

Certification:

  • Fire shields have passed Lloyd’s certification after undergoing performance tests at 1100°C for 120 minutes according to UL 1709:2007.

Emergency Shutoff Valves: According to API RP 553, emergency shutoff valves are designed to prevent uncontrolled release of flammable or toxic substances. If an emergency shutoff valve is located within a fire zone (a minimum radius of 7.6 meters from the leak source), it should be a fire-safe valve. API RP 553 defines four categories of emergency shutoff valves and their respective installation positions.

Contact Us

Please fill out the form below, and we will be in touch within 24 hours.

For urgent inquiry, please feel free to call or add Wechat/Whatsapp via +86 199 2125 0077.